> Kit 18 · The Faithful Copy · deliverable · designed and built by Wayne — instructional design portfolio

## The goal

Adjudicators reach defensible verdicts on borderline dossiers: evidence-weighting distribution matches designed logic in >=80% of audited cases.

## What people do instead

Adjudicators overweight vivid isolated documents or underweight converging patterns; both failure modes produce indefensible appointments.

## The actions that close the gap

| # | Behavior | What it looks like | Where the artifact trains it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | **Tag every document before judging the case** | 12 documents tagged PATTERN / ISOLATED / CONTEXT | tagging phase |
| 2 | **Weigh convergence over vividness** | verdict follows the distribution, not the loudest doc | verdict commit |
| 3 | **Write conditions, not clicks** | appointable-with-conditions requires named conditions | verdict commit |

## What this training will not do

It will not replace the adjudication rubric — it trains the weighting habit the rubric assumes.

## How the artifact scores the actions

Debrief scores the weight distribution, names both failure modes, and reads the written conditions against the pattern.